Not A Bug Populate Not Working With Incubate Tokens

[JLB22]

Match # 260014084 - Game # 843256944

When I cast Sundering Growth targeting and opponent's artiifact, with an Incubator Token (already converted to creature) in play and a Cloakwood Swarmkeeper in game, it doesn't work properly.

I have a 5/5 token, and should get another 5/5 token when populate, and then Cloakwood Swarmkeeper gets a +1/+1.

Funny thing happens: the new token isn't created, but with no new token in game, the Cloakwood Swarmkeeper gets the +1/+1 counter anyways.

It is broken.

Please fix it.

 

[Aldreen]

Incubator tokens are 0/0s with X +1/+1 counters, when you copy the token with populate, it correctly doesn't copy the +1/+1 counters. Cloakwood Swarmkeeper gets a counter because a token was created, it just died as soon as it was, due to being an 0/0.

Not a bug