Could Not Reproduce Show and Tell, Opponent has treachery

twixcow

New member
In Vintage cube, I cast Show and Tell knowing my opponent had Treachery. My thought was that because the two enter at the same time, Treachery does not have a legal target and should go to the graveyard without taking my creature (Archon of Cruelty). However, the Treachery took the creature and I lost the game.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe this is a known bug (Source: https://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums...lings-archives/303278-show-and-tell-treachery). I wasn't able to find it when searching the backlog on this forum, so I apologize if the thread for this already exists.

Game ID: 897570124
 

Torbin

Staff member
Community Team
Tag that needs to be applied: Can Not Reproduce
Testing applied: Cast Treachery while user 1 had Archon of Cruelty in hand and user 2 had Treachery in hand.
Test Results: Treachery had no legal target.
 
Top