In Progress "Everything counter" doesn't include island?

akwehhkanoo

Well-known member
Game ID
882789230
Omo's everything counter, while Omo was on the field and the Omo player was able to block an islandwalk creature (thada Adel)
 
Upvote 3

Neo001992

Well-known member
I went ahead and grabbed one of each of the basic landwalkers for testing, and I was incorrectly able to block all five of them even though I had two lands with Everything Counters on them with Omo, Queen of Vesuva in play.


Event#269902051 Game#882794068
 

Andran

New member
Situation: [[Omo, Queen of Vesuva]] was on the battlefield. Multiple lands had Everything counters on them. I controlled no basic lands. I also had the card [[Collective Restraint]] in play, which requires an opponent to pay X for each attacking creature, where X is the number of basic land types among lands you control (a domain ability). This domain count should've been 5, but was instead 0, suggesting that the lands with Everything counters were not being counted as having all five basic land types. Later I played [[Shifting Woodland]], which enters tapped unless you control a Forest. The lands with Everything counters did not count as a Forest for this purpose, and the land came in tapped. So something is wrong with checking/counting basic land types provided by Omo + Everything counters. Note: The lands with Everything counters were able to tap for land of any color, so they counted as all basic land types for that purpose at least.
 

akwehhkanoo

Well-known member
Game ID #884451564

Other things about Omo and the everything counter, it didn't count toward domain as stated before about collective restraint, but an opponent removed Omo's game text while on the board but lands and creatures with everything counters still could tap for any color and creature had all creature types, without her game text nothing is there to define what everything counters do, so they shouldn't have had that effect while the game text was removed by an enchantment. (Kamina's Transformation)
 

myLAAN

New member
Another issue is that the everything counter on a creature land combined with Embiggen doesn't give the proper buff, but just a +1/+1 instead. E.g. Inkmoth Nexus with an everything counter on it is an Artifact creature land - blinkmoth cave desert forest gate island lair locus mine mountain plains power-plant sphere swamp tower urza's so Embiggen targeting it should give +19/+19.
 
Top